An analysis of 300+ real issues reported by people living in Portugal, and a 5-year plan by AI to fix the country.
300+ posts from residents, expats, and Portuguese locals over 1 year. Posts range from serious systemic critiques to absurd comedy. The most upvoted: 326 votes on AIMA (immigration), 159 votes on dog culture, 147 votes on Lisbon Airport passport gates, and 134 votes on "Portugal only works by knowing someone."
People waiting 2–3+ years for residence permits 326 votes. Family reunification impossible 5 votes. Golden Visa holders scammed 42 votes. Ukrainian refugees still on a PDF after 3 years. EU citizens can't get permanent residency 13 votes. The system is paralyzed - not slow, completely non-functional 13 votes. Multiple people sued AIMA and still got nothing. One guy with $60M to invest in a gym chain was never even allowed to enter 2 votes.
The country runs on circular dependencies: NIF needs address, address needs NIF 5 votes. Bank account needs work contract, work contract needs bank account 45 votes. Citizen card required for everything, but foreigners can't get one 7 votes. Driving license replacement takes over a year 7 votes. Company name registration requires civil court 20 votes. Freelancer setup takes hours vs 10 minutes in France 9 votes. Every process has a "limbo" state where nothing moves 14 votes.
Solar panel guys disappear at 60% 5 votes. Construction workers cut Starlink cables (twice) 30 votes, drill through water pipes 12 votes, install AC tubes vertically so rain shorts the electrics 18 votes, measure kitchen counters wrong 27 votes, start drilling at 7am 29 votes, demand lunch 7 votes, all quit at once 12 votes. Gate destroyed by delivery driver sitting on it 10 votes. Closet guy ghosts after you emptied all closets at midnight 18 votes. Stairs company won't install the stairs they built 3 votes.
The pattern: work starts enthusiastically, quality is poor, accountability is zero, ghosting is the default conflict resolution.
FedEx throws glass mirror over fence 24 votes. $4,000 mattress left in rain 4 votes. DPD uses non-refrigerated van for frozen meat 29 votes. CTT claims supermarket was "closed" 20 votes. DHL delivers to shop instead of house 3 votes. Every delivery requires signature 6 votes. 9 different delivery companies, none reliable. Coffee beans ordered from Lisbon shop never arrive and they say "out of stock" after taking money 3 votes. Package not delivered for 2 years but 5-day claim window expired 2 votes.
Automatic passport gates never work 147 votes. Hours-long immigration queues 18 votes. Baggage chaos 16 votes. Beggars inside terminal 31 votes. Hand sanitizers filled with water 6 votes. Broken faucets 4 votes. 40°C jetways to fake on-time departures 29 votes. Premium parking with break-ins 4 votes. Filthy throughout 21 votes. Voted world's worst airport multiple times by AirHelp.
Town of 30,000 has 16,000 people in queue for a GP 98 votes. Hospital refuses to triage a baby with dangerous fever without SNS phone referral first - "the bureaucracy is killing 42 children per year" 29 votes. Doctor shortage but foreign doctors can't verify degrees 41 votes. SNS24 sends you to a clinic with no doctors 8 votes. CT scan results withheld for missing NIF 10 votes. Health center refuses patients one hour before closing 17 votes. Ukrainian paying taxes for 6 years denied healthcare because expired visa 8 votes.
Government runs Windows XP/Vista 23 votes. Websites constantly broken. Portuguese online stores have insane signup processes while German stores have one-click PayPal. Steam download servers don't work 17 votes. Via Verde can't edit a license plate number 16 votes. CUF/CGD apps show wrong info 20 votes. Palace ticket site has bugs 25 votes. Driving theory school site breaks on signup 18 votes. Invoice requirements absurdly complex 8 votes. Most people order from Amazon Spain or Germany instead 13 votes.
Rimowa store closing at 8pm won't accept you at 4pm 24 votes. Insurance companies never call back 13 votes. Accountants ghost you and keep your documents 8 votes. Companies finish 60% and disappear. Beer tap rental priced per person despite not supplying beer 2 votes. Flower delivery cancelled because "too many foreigners ordered" 9 votes. Furniture company won't deliver above ground floor 4 votes. "Perhaps you do not understand fries" 3 votes.
The consistent theme: zero accountability, zero urgency, and the customer is always wrong.
30.5% effective corporate tax - among the highest in Europe, second only to France 16 votes. Year 3 tax double-hit for new businesses. Banking cartel of 14 banks fined €225M in 2019 28 votes. Banks close at 3pm 39 votes. Millennium rejects Russian applicant who won't buy insurance 8 votes. Novobanco keeps account restricted for years 6 votes. EDP secretly upgrades contract and signs you up for health insurance 4 votes. "Pay the bill too fast" and it breaks their system 50 votes. Tax evasion is "the national sport" 69 votes. NHR status takes years of court battles 9 votes.
Housing crisis with over 723,000 vacant homes (2021 Census), ~485,000 in habitable condition 21 votes. Landlords raise rent 71% between tenants 15 votes. Deposits never returned (universal experience) 34 votes. Need Portuguese guarantor even with Microsoft salary 11 votes. House has 3 different addresses 8 votes. Luxury apartment full of cockroaches and dirt 6 votes.
159 votes on "horrendous abusive dog culture." Dogs chained on balconies barking 24/7, all day and all night, with zero consequences 10 votes. "Walk, Bark, Cry, Repeat" - you can't walk anywhere without endless barking 20 votes. Police threaten Brazilian girlfriend instead of helping with barking dog 7 votes. Dogs locked on terraces when owners go on holiday, howling for days 7 votes. Petition to ban chaining dogs 5 votes. This is a deep cultural issue: the constant barking - morning, afternoon, evening, middle of the night - destroys quality of life for everyone in the neighborhood and nobody does anything about it.
Among the worst traffic death rates in Europe (58 per million vs EU average of 44–45; 5th–6th worst behind Romania and Bulgaria) 35 votes. Nobody understands roundabouts 12 votes. Road rage epidemic 11 votes. Dangerous potholes unreported 23 votes. Derelict unmaintained cars everywhere 4 votes. Double parking and blocking is normalized. Cash-only parking meters in 2025 30 votes. IMT system goes down Portugal-wide on your appointment day 7 votes.
About 30 posts are from Portuguese people or are reactions to the site. They split into three groups:
Portugal's GDP per capita is ~$29K vs Germany's ~$55K. The entire system - infrastructure, tech, healthcare, courts - was built for a poorer, simpler society. There was never enough tax revenue to modernize because the economy never grew enough because the bureaucracy prevented growth 33 votes. It's a vicious cycle. The 30.5% effective corporate tax (among the highest in Europe) drives businesses to Spain (25%), which keeps wages low, which keeps tax revenue low.
"Portugal only works by knowing someone who knows someone" 134 votes. One post identifies the four parallel universes of getting things done 21 votes: by phone (never works - you get transferred endlessly or told to come in person), by email (ignored - no response for weeks or months), in person without connections (long waits, arbitrary rules, often rejected), and in person with cunha (connections) - everything works instantly, doors open, rules bend. This isn't a bug - it's how the country has functioned for centuries. The problem is it can't scale. When you add hundreds of thousands of immigrants and expats who don't have cunha, the system reveals itself as fundamentally exclusive.
"Pessimism and 'it is what it is' mentality" 37 votes and "mediocrity as standard" 10 votes describe the same thing: a collective action problem. Any individual Portuguese person who tries harder gets no reward because the system doesn't reward excellence. The tradesperson who shows up on time doesn't get more business because there's no competition - there aren't enough tradespeople. The government worker who processes things faster doesn't get promoted. So everyone settles into "é o que é" (it is what it is).
The deepest irony: Portugal created visa programs (Golden Visa, NHR, D7) to attract wealthy foreigners. Those foreigners came with money and high expectations. They discovered the systems don't work. They built a website documenting every failure. Now Portuguese people are angry at the foreigners for complaining. But one of the most upvoted posts on the entire site is from a Portuguese person saying the exact same thing: "Portugal only works by knowing someone" 134 votes.
The country isn't broken because foreigners are complaining. Foreigners are complaining because the country is broken. And the Portuguese know it - they just don't want outsiders to be the ones saying it.
A brutally pragmatic plan based on 300+ real complaints from people living there.
Portugal doesn't have 300+ separate problems. It has about 5 root causes that produce 300+ symptoms. Fix the roots and most symptoms disappear on their own:
Everything else - the broken airport, the ghosting contractors, the 3-year immigration waits, the barking dogs, the cash-only parking meters - flows from these five things.
Revenue impact: Short-term loss of maybe 10–15% of tax revenue. Offset by spending cuts and recovered within 2–3 years from increased economic activity and reduced evasion. Estonia did this. Ireland did this. It works every time.
AIMA is beyond saving. 400,000+ backlogged cases. People waiting 3 years. The organization is paralyzed.
Portugal has one of the highest ratios of public servants to population in the EU - roughly one civil servant for every 17.6 people, compared to one per 33.4 in Spain - yet the services are terrible.
Pass a single, simple law: if a business or government service commits to a date or service level, and fails to deliver, there are automatic financial consequences.
The mechanism is simple: make failing to deliver more expensive than delivering.
The country's front door and an international embarrassment.
The dog barking situation is out of control. Dogs bark endlessly - morning, afternoon, evening, all through the night - and nobody does anything. It's both an animal welfare crisis and a quality of life disaster for every neighborhood in the country.
Over 723,000 vacant homes (per the 2021 Census) while there's a housing crisis. About 485,000 are in habitable condition.
Publish monthly. Hold ministers accountable. Targets not met = minister replaced.
Create something like the Dutch SIRE foundation - an independent NGO funded by the advertising industry that has run 122+ social awareness campaigns since 1967:
One ultimate measurement: net migration of skilled Portuguese workers. Currently Portugal bleeds talent - educated young people leave for Germany, Netherlands, UK, Switzerland because they see no future.
If the reforms work, this reverses. Portuguese engineers, doctors, and entrepreneurs start coming home because taxes are competitive (15–25% vs 40–50% in Northern Europe), starting a business takes 48 hours not 6 months, the courts work, the healthcare works, the infrastructure works - and the weather is still better than Amsterdam.
That's the real test. Not whether expats stop complaining on onlyinportugal.com - but whether Portuguese people start choosing to stay.
The gap is almost entirely caused by self-inflicted wounds: a tax system that punishes productivity, a bureaucracy that prevents action, and an accountability vacuum that rewards mediocrity.
Every single complaint here traces back to one of these three things. Fix them and in 5 years you don't have a complaints website - you have a country that people are fighting to get into, not fighting to survive in.
Portugal already has the hardest things to create: geographic beauty, cultural richness, safety, EU membership, and a generally kind population. Those things can't be built. The things that are broken - systems, processes, infrastructure - are the easy things to fix. They just require the political will to do it.
Give Portugal a competent strategy and watch what happens.
Portugal has the potential to be one of Europe's top countries. But nothing changes without pressure.
Sign this petition to support the reforms outlined above. Every signature tells Portugal's leaders: we see the problems, and we demand better.
By signing, you agree to be shown on the supporters page.